Dupe for Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Cap-toe Oxford
Park Avenue Cap-toe OxfordAvailable on allenedmonds.com >
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Cap Toe | Formal Dress ShoeAvailable on amazon.com >
Why buy the alternative?
Save $235 (59%) on amazon.com
Shoppers say the alternative is like Allen Edmonds
Reviews by Users
These reviews from all over the web show how similar Johnston Murphy is.
Great alternative to Allen Edmonds Park Avenue
I purchased a pair of these in Black and Bordeaux. It's funny because I was actually looking for a pair of Park Avenue's to add to my collection, but they were on Amazon deals for under $50 bucks each. I'm not new to J&M, but I'm glad I decided to give their lower end O... Read More
These shoes are exceptional for the price. At relatively short notice, I was looking for a cheaper iteration of the black Oxford captoe, in the same vein as the Allen Edmonds Park Avenue, and these have so far been an excellent substitute. They were true to size, and ha... Read More
An Elegant Dress Shoe for Men, not Boys
In an age of cheaply made, poorly looking formal and semi-formal men's footwear, Johnston & Murphy is light beyond the rest. The fit, the form and the fashion of this shoe is smart, stylish and sophisticated. Not to mention, it is comfortable, so comfortable I can run i... Read More
Best pair of dress shoes I've ever owned
These are, hands-down, the most comfortable dress shoes I have ever owned. Up until buying these shoes I would wear sneakers on my walk to work, and change shoes once I arrived. These shoes are comfortable enough to wear while walking every day. They also look incredibl... Read More
Good quality, affordable, classic style dress shoe
I purchased the J&M Melton's five months ago. For the price they are one of the better dress shoes available. I purchased in my typical size, 11D, and they fit as expected. When compared to Allen Edmonds shoes like the Strand that I own the fit is very similar. Also go... Read More
We'll always suggest the lowest price that's in stock.
Never Miss A Dupe With Our Free Chrome Extension.
As you shop online, we'll let you know the best alternative to save you money.
Note: ShopDiffy is an affiliate partner with Amazon and several other vendors and influencers. When you click a link and make a purchase, ShopDiffy or our influencer partners may receive a small payment, which helps us find great alternatives and keeps the site running. Each alternative is authentically selected and we’ll never sacrifice the quality of our alternative. This document may refer to brand names that are trademarks or registered trademarks of manufacturers that do not sponsor or have any affiliation with the manufacturer of this alternative product to which they are being compared.
You may also be interested in...
Did you know you can search a variety of categories and brands?