Dupe for Benefit Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil
Why buy the alternative?
Save $14 (56%) on ulta.com
Shoppers say the alternative is like Benefit
2 matching ingredients
stearic acid, ethylhexyl palmitate
Reviews by Users
These reviews from all over the web show how similar Nyx is.
Favorite brow pencil
I have used this brow pencil for years. Great pigmentation, smooth application, and lasts all day during my 12+ hour shifts. I love the angle of this pencil versus the super skinny point of other pencils. This gives me more of the powder brow/feathery brow look dependi... Read More
This is super pencil for pale blondes when going for the no makeup look. Many time since pandemic I don't bother with eye makeup at all, however my brows are so thin and light they need help. This blonde pencil goes on really light (you can layer it darker if you want).... Read More
Exceeds my expectations
I didn't think this would be as good as benefit goof proof because of the price. I was wrong ! This is just as good for half the cost and I will keep buying until they stop making them but please don't stop making them lol
Better than the more expensive ones
Ive invested in more expensive eyebrow pencils (such as the benefit cosmetics precise eyebrow pencil) and this one is just as good, if not better, for a way lower price. Love it.
LISTEN TO ME RIGHT NOW...
LISTEN TO ME RIGHT NOW. I have tried literally every brow pencil/product under the sun. I am a brow product hoarder. ABH, Benefit etc. I have been using the NYX powder pencils off and on, but was never completely happy because I get so sick of having to sharpen them. I ... Read More
We'll always suggest the lowest price that's in stock.
Never Miss A Dupe With Our Free Chrome Extension.
As you shop online, we'll let you know the best alternative to save you money.
Note: ShopDiffy is an affiliate partner with Amazon and several other vendors and influencers. When you click a link and make a purchase, ShopDiffy or our influencer partners may receive a small payment, which helps us find great alternatives and keeps the site running. Each alternative is authentically selected and we’ll never sacrifice the quality of our alternative. This document may refer to brand names that are trademarks or registered trademarks of manufacturers that do not sponsor or have any affiliation with the manufacturer of this alternative product to which they are being compared.
Did you know you can search a variety of categories and brands?