Reviews for Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Snow Boot

People say Columbia is really similar to Sorel.


These boots are wonderful!

I haven't had a new pair of boots for over 20 years and the boots I had (Sorel) were the best, but wanted to get a pair of boots that matched my jacket. I went with the gray and I love them. I have gotten so many compliments. They fit perfect. I am an 8 1/2 and so I bought a 9 and have plenty of room for a pair of wool socks. They are also waterproof. Last weekend in slushy weather in Wisconsin, stepped in slushy puddles and feet stayed warm and dry. Also, these boots don't "clomp". You know when you are walking and they make that sound. These don't have that. They wear really well. For Columbia and the price, they made an excellent product. Plan on buying a pair for my daughter.


WARM, Lightweight, comfortable, stylish!

These boots are fantastic! I live in Michigan where it’s cold and snowy 5-6 months of the year, so warm, comfortable boots are essential, and I am not sure how I’ve been living without these! They are SUPER lightweight and comfortable, and soooo warm. With the recent restaurant shutdown, my husband and I have been spending a lot of time outside at restaurants that offer safe outdoor seating and my feet were getting cold in 35-40 degree weather after only 30 minutes in my expensive Pajar and Sorel boots, so wanted to try these and was NOT disappointed. Great price point for a very stylish, comfortable and warm boot. Easy to get on and off, and very easy to walk in, not clunky like other winter boots. Buy these, you won’t regret it!


Warm and stylish

I’ve had these boots for a month now. Live in Tahoe and have been in ice and snow. I was looking for an alternative to my heavy clunky Sorels. These fit the bill keep my feet dry and warm and yet are sufficiently light enough I can feel the pedals when I drive. I’ve worn Altra running shoes for the last few years so these emulate them. Wider front toe box for my bunions and a zero drop feel. Good grip when I walk. Would buy again.