Reviews for Retractable Long-Lasting Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil
People say Nyx is really similar to Stila.
Best Eyeliner Ever!
I have 4 of these. They are hands down better than Stila smudge stick and waaaayyyyy less expensive and much easier to glide on. The gray one is awesome as an every day less bold alternative to black...it's not too dark, not too light. The olive one is great for brown eyes. I won't bother with prestige brand liner anymore.
My Go To Eyeliner
I'm used to using the equivalent version of the Stila eyeliner, but now that I'm in college and have to use my money to pay bills, I can't exactly afford higher end makeup. This eyeliner by Nyx is the first eyeliner I have found that looks and feels the same as the Stila one. It's AMAZING. The only con is it's difficult to remove, but I mean come on, is that really a con?
As good as high end brands at a great price
This is my go to everyday liner. I would be lost without it. Have used Stila, MAC and dept store brands but come back to this.
I got this to replace my expensive stila liner. This one is cooler/more neutral than the reddish brown from stila, but I still enjoy the color! So far two weeks and two uses in, it's still creamy. I hope it doesn't dry out quickly, but either way it's very affordable!
Love the affordability of this eyeliner. It is smooth and glides on easily, but not so smooth that it smudges all over the place. Easily smoked/blended the liner out. This replaced my retractable Stila eyeliner that was far more expensive and it performs just as well!
Better than Stila and Hourglass
Very good pigment with staying power. Although I have not found a holy grail that doesn't smudge or run at all under any condition, this one comes really close! It lasts longer than the premier brands Stila and Hourglass at a fraction of the cost. Will purchase again!
This was more of an impulse buy than anything. I lost my blue Stila liner and decided to replace it with something more blendable while picking up some basics. I pretty much grabbed the first pencil I saw, that was inexpensive, in case it wasn't going to work for me. Surprise! I love it! Goes on so smoothly, a plus for lids on women of a certain age. I use it on my upper and lower lash lines, sometime as a liner, and sometimes just at the outside corner of my eye. I can really change the look by applying more or less. It's very blendable. This is a little brighter blue than the Stila lliner but that's a good thing - it's not at all garish.
Comparable to Stila's Lionfish liner
I was really impressed with this liner when I bought it. It's just like Stila's Lionfish liner that I have repurchased time & again over the years. Now that I've found a less expensive version with the same quality I'll most likely be repurchasing NYX's liner time & again.
Better than high-end brands
I recently switched to NYX liner from stila waterproof liner and there is no difference in product. The only difference is about $18 in price. Another awesome NYX product!
Love these eyeliner!
I was surprised when I picked up these NYX liners in a few different colors because they are so cheap but work so well! They remind me of my Stila smudge sticks but are a little smaller. They go on so creamy!
Great price. Works well.
I have long been a 24/7 UD liner user. It started running on me so I was looking for a new liner. I bought this and Stila's retractable. This doesn't go on as smooth as Stila, but the Stila doesn't contain much product and costs $$ more.
This is a great product for the price. It works as well as any more expensive liner (Laura Mercier, Urban Decay, Stila and Clinique).