Reviews for e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Felt Tip, Waterproof Liquid Formula, Jet Black, 0.02 Fl Oz (0.7mL)

People say Elf is really similar to Stila.



In all seriousness, I don’t write reviews, but i love make up and I think people deserve to know how amazing this product is. My skin is super oily, i have tried different waterproof eyeliners like urban decay perversion and Stila, they do work for me for 12 hours, then it starts to transfer. This product lasted me over 24 hours, and for the price, it cannot get any better. Do yourself a favor and buy this!! It is so easy to apply, it’s super black, you won’t regret it


Just like the Stila eyeliner

I wanted a swap for my 22 stila eyeliner which is excellent. I researched what a good dupe was this elf liner was recommended. This is my first time using this brand but it’s just as good as the stila version. I have hooded eyes so a lot of eyeliners smear but not this one! It lasts all day and it saves me a lot of dough. Highly recommend!


Favorite waterproof eyeliner

Best waterproof eyeliner & the least expensive! I've tried other waterproof eyeliners - Wunder (flaky & clumpy), Honest (not truly waterproof & smeared badly) & Stila (smudged) but this one stays put & doesn't smear or smudge & comes off with eye makeup remover easily.


Better Than Stila

This eyeliner is my go-to - I live in Texas and the heat means more smudging, but not with this eyeliner!