Reviews for L'Oreal Paris Cosmetics Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner, Black, 0.042 Ounce,1 Count
People say Loreal Paris is really similar to Urban Decay.
Glides on easily. Does not cause sensitivity. Very comparable to Urban Decay’s 24/7 eyeliner.
For tightlining on hooded, extremely oily eyes ... Yowza! Stays PUT all day!
TIGHTLINE PROCEDURE: applied, then opened eyes wide with little blinking for 1 minute. COLOR: very nice, deep purple (no sparkle or metallic tinges). The color rivaled but wasn't as rich as Urban Decay 24/7. (But UD smudged on my hooded, extremely oily eyes & disappeared by the end of the day.) NO SMUDGING: woo hoooo! No smudging on top or below eyes throughout the day. Some fading, but not marked. I don't ever re-apply so more than enough color left to make me happy. REMOVAL: with Neutrogena Oil-Free Makeup Remover on a cotton pad, I gently press it on my eyelid & then with the pad, roll my upper lid just ever so slightly & keep the pad on the tightlined area for a few seconds. After, I wait 20-30 seconds, and then swipe several times with the pad again. This removes all or most of the liner. I wouldn't qualify this as an easy to remove liner, but it's easy enough given the all-day wear. Also, for perspective, I do not wear mascara. Lastly, I don't wear contacts so I can't speak to whether this liner would cause irritation. DEFINITELY HG! I'm a relative minimalist with makeup. 5-10 minutes at most with SPF, pressed powder, loose powder, lite blush, eyebrows, & tightline liner. Because of its outstanding color & all-day staying power (into 9-10 pm), it's easily become my HG liner!
Better than Urban Decay
I’m always on the search for a good eyeliner this stuff fits the bill. I have bought urban decay 24 seven for years and I hate spending the $22 it now cost for a pencil this is a bargain at nine dollars and lasts just as good if not better
Great Alternative to Urban Decay
I typically love the eyeliners from Urban Decay but this one is a contender. It’s easy to put on, wallet friendly and Bronze is just the right shade to add definition without being too much.
this is the best eyeliner i've ever used
this is the best eyeliner i've ever used. i have been an Urban Decay 24-7 pencil user for a while along with a lot of liquid liners.. this is the first pencil that stays on all day without smudging.. especially when you use a primer. Easy to apply/sharpen. Will buy again.
Only eyeliner that stays on wet line!
Love this eyeliner! Have tried a bunch of other products, this one is the best! It definitely works better than Urban decay and cheaper! Will never buy any other eyeliner again! A must try if you haven’t yet, you will love it!
A Review From my Wife
This eye liner seemed very familiar the first time I opened it and put it on. In looks, application, and wear, it is almost exactly Urban Decay 24/7 Glide On. It is so similar to that product that I mistakenly picked up one of my Urban Decay 24/7 pencils in Perversion and wondered why in the world the grey was suddenly so dark. I normally wear black, black eye liner. But as greys go, this one is lovely. It isn’t a product I would use on my lower lid; it’s just too mushy for that. Unfortunately I find that most of the eye liners I’ve tried (save for L’Oreal’s Le Kohl pencil in Carbon Black, which is impossible to find in the US now). But for doing the upper lid, especially for those of us who love the liquid liner look but don’t have the skills, it’s perfect. I will definitely buy it again (oh darn, it doesn’t come in Carbon Black?) given the price is around $8.00 as compared to the Urban Decay (which goes for around $20.00).
Good drugstore option for graphic liner newbs.
Super long lasting and very bold hued, I found this eyeliner a fun swap on my waterline over the black I usually use. Graphic liner is totally on trend right now and this is a good drugstore version for anyone who wants to try it without the $$ commitment of luxe brands like Urban Decay or stila.